MR. TITO: WWE is just a Roman Reigns Injury Away from Failure

Follow Mr. Tito on Twitter by going to the following link: @titowrestling


On the night of Survivor Series 1999, the WWE ran an injury angle where Stone Cold Steve Austin was the victim of a hit and run with a car. For the next 9 months or so, the WWE would have to learn to without Steve Austin and primarily pushed a babyface Rock and the recently pushed heel Triple H in his place. If you look at TV Viewership numbers and Pay Per View buyrates through late 1999 and through the Spring of 2000, numbers remained steady… However, according to Jim Ross on his Grilling J.R. podcasts, Houseshow ticket sales began to cool as early as late 1999 and merchandise sales began to slow down. Following the McMahon lovefest known as Wrestlemania 16, WWE’s television viewership began to decline and RAW’s numbers had annual decreases until 2005.

Back then, while the WWE bench was very deep, especially as 2000 rolled around… Steve Austin was the WWE’s main attraction and WWE lost many casual fans who tuned in just to see him. Then, when Austin came back later during the year, the WWE landscape had changed. WWE was becoming more corporate, Triple H was attending production meetings, and WWE was beginning to transition Stephanie McMahon into being Creative Lead (Triple H’s girlfriend). While Austin did his best to regain his top spot, it was obvious that Triple H had become too powerful backstage in his absence and Austin even did a clean job for him at No Way Out 2001 and later teamed with him as a heel after Wrestlemania 17. WWE would continue to decline throughout late 2000 and then really declined during 2001 with Austin’s foolish heel turn and then failed WCW/ECW Alliance angle.

FAST FORWARD to the Summer of 2020. WWE Smackdown on FOX was beginning to trend downward. In fact, for 7 straight weeks before the week of WWE SummerSlam 2020, Smackdown was UNDER 2 million viewers consecutively. Roman Reigns made his return at SummerSlam 2020 and then officially turned heel shortly thereafter when Paul Heyman joined him. Since Roman’s post SummerSlam 2020 return, the WWE has rarely been under 2 million viewers since August 2020.

BUT let me run this scenario by you… And I want to 100% stress that I want Roman Reigns to prove to be the most durable wrestler ever. WHAT IF, however, he gets injured? God forbid, what if Leukemia happens to return for a 3rd time? (I pray not!) Or even this… what if he received his 2nd WWE Wellness Violation? He was busted the first time during 2016 and had a 30 day suspension. The 2nd violation equates to 60 day suspension (plus reputational harm) and the 3rd would equate to a termination by the WWE.

I the latter examples (Leukemia, Wellness Policy) are the extremes, but ACL, Quads, Biceps, Triceps, Pectorals, and Rotator Cuffs tear. Roman is 36 years old with 11 years of mileage piled up on his body in addition to many years on the football field. With today’s unsafe style of wrestling with no-disqualification matches, something could happen. How about that violent match he had with Kevin Owens at Royal Rumble 2021? You never know when that neck could break or discs in the spine could displace.

If Roman Reigns were to get injured, who could replace him as the marquee name of WWE Smackdown?

Seth Rollins? Tried pushing him for years as a Main Eventer.

The Fiend/Bray Wyatt? See 2019-2020 as Smackdown headliner.

Anyone from RAW, such as Bobby Lashley or Drew McIntyre? They are beginning to draw 1.7 million viewers or less over there on USA Network.

You could always bring back John Cena, Brock Lesnar, or CM Punk, but you better bring the BRINKS Truck to pay each of those wrestlers.

You’ve got NOTHING in the NXT promotion at all to step up immediately, too. Don’t give me Karrion Kross, as the WWE Main Event show just exposed him without giving him a hot female manager and an overproduced entrance. There is NOTHING on the NXT bench that is ready to call up and make an impact immediately.

If Roman Reigns were to be unable to continue performing on WWE Smackdown, the WWE is SO SCREWED!

In case you haven’t watched WWE Smackdown lately, the surrounding show is awful but the beginning and endings are great because of Roman Reigns. The show would be every bit as bad as Monday Night RAW if Roman wasn’t the featured star on the show. Without him, the WWE Creative Team of failed Hollywood writers, comedians, and other non-wrestling fans would get completely exposed and Smackdown would quickly begin looking like RAW.

Then, WWE Smackdown begins to lose viewership on FOX… How low could we go? After all, WWE Smackdown is on Friday Nights when many people typically go out on a date or hit the bars after a long work week. Without Roman, the WWE has to rely on the same old tired names who have already been World Champion repeatedly and a bunch fo wrestlers under 6 feet tall in NXT. WWE has no contingency plans for replacing Roman as their top guy.

Back on May 11th, I wrote a column entitled “Should AEW Dynamite Move to Monday Nights to Challenge WWE RAW?”. Many of you laughed at it back then but if you look at the numbers, All Elite Wrestling (AEW) is closer to the WWE than many think. WWE RAW is averaging 1.7 million and trending downward right now while WEDNESDAY Night AEW Dynamite can do anywhere between 700,000 to 1,000,000 viewers (it varies). Compared to what TNA saw during the early 2010s, they were up against a much stronger WWE that was averaging around 4.5 million viewers. Hence why they lost… TNA had to make up over 2.5 million viewers whereas AEW just has to close a gap of 1 million or less and the WWE is helping them by continuing to decline.

WWE without Roman Reigns is completely vulnerable. No Roman, no consistency of having 2 million viewers for WWE Smackdown. Then, during 2024 when the television deal with FOX expires… What now?

As I have said repeatedly now, this is what happens when you don’t take your Training, Recruiting, and Talent Recruiting seriously. Triple H built a Performance Center and then opted tryout seminars at his Center to determine future WWE wrestlers. Compare that to Jim Ross, Gerald Brisco, and others recruiting athletes from different backgrounds. For example, Gerald Brisco was heavily recruiting Brock Lesnar to join the WWE and spent YEARS speaking to Lesnar and his coaches at the University of Minnesota. While going after Lesnar, they noticed that Shelton Benjamin was quite an amazing talent too. Instead for recent times, WWE is holding tryouts at the Performance Center which invites people who THINK that they want to become Pro Wrestlers. Yet, the intangibles of a top drawing superstar should be scouted across the country.

Let me create a scary scenario for you… Roman Reigns gets injured and AEW makes a big splash signing like CM Punk, Brock Lesnar, or John Cena. I say that scenario is DOUBTFUL because AEW is a hot mess and no high profile wrestlers want to work for the 4 EVPs (Bucks, Cody, Omega). But in my opinion, AEW could take the lead against a vulnerable WWE without Reigns.

June 27th, 2011 marked the 10 anniversary of the infamous “pipebomb” speech by CM Punk on WWE Monday Night RAW. Since John Cena made it as a superstar during 2004-2005, nobody but CM Punk has ever come close to becoming a major breakout star. That “Summer of Punk” was powerful and drew huge numbers back then. Then, the WWE botched the weeks after Money in the Bank 2011 win, forced Alberto Del Rio to win his WWE Title, and then Triple H shoveled the last dirt onto his momentum with their feud. Never being able to actually Main Event RAW or Pay Per Views as champion during 2012 and Punk lost to everybody during 2013. Punk is 42, going on 43… Time is running out, though him just cutting promos, alone, would be a good draw.

AEW has to purge its awful Executive Vice Presidents who have signed the wrong talents for this start-up, are disorganized on their creative, and aren’t impressing much themselves as in-ring performers. Put some experienced wrestling hands in charge of talent recruitment and creative and maybe consider hiring CM Punk to join that process.

WWE is a disaster. Creative is BAD, Talent Development is AWFUL, and WWE’s push investment in Roman Reigns from 2014-2020 caused many WWE wrestlers to fall by the wayside. Who knows? Dean Ambrose, Cody Rhodes, Rusev, Braun Strowman, Bray Wyatt, CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, and many others would have gone on to be a top star in the WWE if they didn’t have to sell and lose to Roman Reigns during his 2014-2020 babyface push. While Roman figured it out by August 2020 by becoming a heel, it still doesn’t replace the damage done to other talents selling for him for what the WWE tried for 6-7 years before Roman finally “got it”.

WWE has no bench and doing all of these “Spring Cleaning” post-Wrestlemania releases has thinned their roster of choices and NXT has nobody ready to takeover immediately as needed. WWE’s long-term prospects look bad.

Nick Khan might be good at making the WWE more profitable, but he sure as hell cannot account for the Creative Team or Talent Relations. Doing all of those talent cuts while not building proper contingency plans for the talent harm the WWE soon. If Roman Reigns gets hurt for a substantial amount of time, negotiating for that next FOX deal could become difficult.

If the WWE isn’t trying to create a back-up for Roman Reigns as the top guy… Then maybe WWE is truly for sale?

So just chill… Until the next episode!

Comments and feedback are welcome. Follow and Tweet me @titowrestling or login in below to post comments.



06/26/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – More WWE Talent Releases, John Cena Return?, Edge Vs. Roman Reigns, Rhea Ripley, and More
06/22/2021 – WWE Hell in a Cell, Extreme Rules, Money in the Bank, and TLC are AWFUL Pay Per View Events
06/19/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – USA Network Upset at WWE?, Samoa Joe NXT Return, Eva Marie, LA Knight, Hell in a Cell Predictions, & More
06/15/2021 – How Wrestlers, Such as Alexa Bliss, Are Exposing Pro Wrestling with their Personal Lifes and Social Media
06/12/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE SummerSlam, Alexa Bliss, Bella Twins, AEW on Fridays, NXT Takeover Predictions, The Rock Returning?, and More
06/08/2021 – Reasons Why Braun Strowman Struggled in the WWE and Was Eventually Released
06/05/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Andrade and Mark Henry in AEW, Booker T’s Comments on Aleister Black, More on WWE Cuts, and More
06/03/2021 – Does the Recent WWE Releases (Braun Strowman, Aleister Black, Lana, etc.) + Prior Firings = WWE for Sale?
06/02/2021 – The Top 5 Greatest Nintendo 64 Pro Wrestling Video Games
05/31/2021 YouTube Video – Unwrestled Mysteries: The Infamous Macho Man Randy Savage and Stephanie McMahon RUMOR
05/29/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE & New Japan, Ultimate Warrior Documentaries, John Cena/China, AEW Double or Nothing Predictions, More
05/25/2021 – WWE Creative Has Ruined Lives and Caused Unemployment for Many Wrestlers
05/22/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Zombies in WWE, Velveteen NXT Release, AEW Dynamite Television Changes, and More
05/18/2021 – Tony Khan’s Jacksonville Jaguars Signing Tim Tebow is Like AEW EVPs Signing Talent
05/15/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Zelina Vega Returns to WWE, Velveteen Dream, Miro Wins TNT Title, RIP New Jack, and More
05/11/2021 – Should AEW Dynamite Move to Monday Nights to Challenge WWE RAW?
05/08/2021 – YouTube Video: The Great Debate between Mr. Tito and Virtue – The Future of WWE with Roman Reigns, early AEW vs. Current AEW, and WWE Women’s Rankings
05/08/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Daniel Bryan, Mick Foley on WWE’s Women’s Wrestling, Eva Maria, and More
05/04/2021 – The Future of Roman Reigns in the WWE: Remain Heel or Return to Babyface?
04/27/2021: Without Tony Khan, Things Could Actually Be Worse in AEW
04/24/2021: Ask Mr. Tito – Mickie James and WWE Garbage Bags, CM Punk, Ronda Rousey’s Pregnancy, More
04/20/2021: How to Repair Seth Rollins’s WWE Character
04/17/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE Releases, Charlotte’s Return, Pat McAfee on Smackdown, NXT/AEW Viewership, & More
04/13/2021 – Celebrity Newcomers Should NOT Dominate Pro Wrestling Veterans in the Ring
04/11/2021Mr. Tito’s PHAT WWE Wrestlemania 37 Night #2 Review with Match Ratings and Show Grade
04/10/2021 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT WWE Wrestlemania 37 Night #1 Review with Match Ratings and Show Grade
04/10/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE’s Post Wrestlemania 37 Plans, Becky Lynch’s WWE Return, All-Time Wrestlemania Questions, More
04/07/2021 – Should Hulk Hogan Be a WWE Co-Host for Wrestlemania 37?
04/06/2021 – WWE Wrestlemania 37 Predictions – Who Should Win and Who Will Win?
04/03/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Chris Jericho on Steve Austin’s WWE Network Show, Hurt Business, and More
03/30/2021 – What if Rob Van Dam Wasn’t Suspended During 2006 in WWE?
03/27/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Peacock Censoring WWE, Daniel Bryan, More
03/24/2021 – Supernatural Stuff Has No Place in Pro Wrestling
03/22/2021 – Edge = Wrong WWE Veteran for Roman Reigns
03/20/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Cornette/Miro, WWE Fastlane, Bischoff, More
03/16/2021 – Triple H is the Ultimate WWE Yes Man
03/13/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – John Laurinaitis for WWE Talent Relations, More
03/09/2021 – Forget Christian in AEW, Where is CM Punk?
03/06/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – AEW Big Surprise, Shaq, Crockett, & More
03/03/2021 – Statistical Findings on AEW Dynamite’s Viewership
02/27/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Gina Carano in WWE?, Paul Wight/AEW, More
02/23/2021 – The Problem with the Miz as WWE Champion
02/20/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Lacey Evans & Ric Flair, Jim Ross, and More
02/16/2021 – How to Push Big E in the WWE
02/13/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Nia Jax, Sammy Guevara, Edge, and More
02/09/2021 – Are WWE Wrestlers Softer Now than Before?
02/06/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Follow-up on HHH, Bianca Belair, Lars, and More
02/02/2021 – Triple H’s Incompetence Helped Edge Win Rumble
01/31/2021 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT WWE Royal Rumble 2021 Review
01/30/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Ronda Rousey, WWE Rumble Surprises, More
01/26/2021 – WWE Network, NBCU’s Peakcock, and YOU
01/25/2021 – What Makes the WWE Royal Rumble Great
01/23/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Bryan/Nakamura, USA Network & WWE, More
01/20/2021 – What is Wrong with Being a WWE Cruiserweight?
01/16/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Chris Jericho, Roman vs. Owens, More
01/13/2021 – How the WWE Can Use Nostalgia to Grow Again
01/09/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Donald Trump & WWE Hall of Fame, More
01/06/2021 – The TRUTH About New Japan Pro Wrestling
01/02/2021 – Ask Mr. Tito – Brodie Lee/AEW, Luke Harper/WWE, More
12/31/2020 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT 2021 Wrestling Predictions
12/26/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE Creative, Slammys, Rousey, More
12/25/2020 – My 2020 Awards & Wishlist for 2021
12/21/2020 – For 2021, the WWE Should REDUCE Ticket Prices
12/19/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE/USA Network, TLC Predictions, More
12/18/2020 – WWE Should Bring Back Jim Ross
12/15/2020 – Is Kenny Omega a Draw to Wrestling Fans?
12/11/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – AEW/Impact, Sting, 2021 WWE Rumble, More
12/08/2020 – Why Do Fans Hate Chris Jericho Now?
12/03/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Sting, Patterson, AEW/Impact, and More
12/01/2020 – In Defense of WWE’s Vince McMahon…
11/28/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Lana & Nia Jax, Undertaker, and More
11/26/2020 (Thanksgiving) – Top WWE Survivor Series Moments
11/24/2020 – WWE and Wrestlers Need Better Marketing
11/22/2020 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT WWE Survivor Series 2020 Review
11/21/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Kenny Omega Hall of Fame?, Zelina Vega, and More
11/19/2020 – Can Zelina Vega Survive as a Twitch Streamer?
11/14/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Zelina Vega’s WWE Release, Bellas, More
11/11/2020 – How to FIX Brandi Rhodes in AEW
11/6/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Sting in AEW?, Full Gear Predictions, and More
11/2/2020 – The POSITIVES in Pro Wrestling Right Now
10/30/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Jericho, Hager, WWE 3Q Financials, and More
10/28/2020 – 1998 = Peak of Wrestling and American Politics
10/25/2020 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT WWE Hell in a Cell 2020 Review
10/24/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Jericho/MJF, WWE Hell in a Cell Predictions, More
10/21/2020 – Wrestling Fans and COVID-19
10/17/2020 – YouTube Video: The Great Debate between Mr. Tito and Virtue – Roman Reigns, Bray Wyatt/Fiend, and Vince Russo vs. Paul Heyman
10/17/2020 – WWE Draft, Roman’s Submission Hold, and More
10/14/2020 – Good, Bad, & Ugly of the WWE Draft
10/9/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – WWE Draft, Retribution, Cody/TNT, More
10/7/2020 – AEW and NBA Gambling on 18-49 Demo
10/3/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – The Rock’s Politics, Roman Reigns, and More
9/29/2020 – WWE Needs to Appreciate Paul Heyman
9/26/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Road Warrior Animal, Retribution, and More
9/23/2020 – The Rock and John Cena Returning to the WWE?
9/19/2020 – WWE 2K Battlegrounds Video Game Review
9/16/2020 – My Job Application to Join WWE Creative
9/12/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Miro in AEW, Tessa Blanchard, More
9/8/2020 – Time for AEW To GROW UP
9/5/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Sasha/Bayley, Jey Uso, and More
9/1/2020 – The Value of Brock Lesnar to the WWE
8/30/2020 – WWE Payback Review & Roman Reigns
8/29/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Roman Reigns & Paul Heyman, More
8/26/2020 – Who Wants to be the Next WWE Main Eventer?
8/23/2020 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT WWE SummerSlam 2020 Review
8/22/2020 – Mr. Tito’s PHAT NXT Takeover XXX Review
8/22/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Rene Young, WWE Thunderdome, and More
8/18/2020 – Maybe WWE Has a Triple H Problem?
8/15/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Randy Orton/Ric Flair, Dixie Carter, Kamala, Pat McAfee, and More
8/13/2020 – YouTube Video: What’s Wrong with Wrestling – Foreign Objects
8/11/2020 – Does AEW have an EVP Problem?
8/9/2020 – YouTube Video: The Positives in Pro Wrestling for 2020
8/8/2020 – Ask Mr. Tito – Adam Cole vs. Pat McAfee, Rock vs. Daniel Bryan?, Blood in AEW, and Much More
8/4/2020 – WWE is an Unorganized Hot Mess
8/1/2020 – WWE and AEW Blew It with COVID-19

© Mr. Tito and – 2020-2021