Opinions

The most underrated AEW wrestlers heading into 2025

Albert Irving

As AEW heads into 2025, several wrestlers stand out as underrated or underutilized talents who could benefit from bigger roles. Here’s a look at some examples…

Malakai Black

While a fan favorite and leader of the House of Black, Black has been notably absent from key events and tournaments like the Continental Classic. His unique dark persona and strong wrestling style have fans hoping for a more prominent singles role in AEW​.

Roderick Strong

Although Strong has performed impressively with a solid 2024 win record, his mid-card status feels underwhelming given his abilities. He has shone in bouts against Orange Cassidy and Kyle O’Reilly, but fans argue his consistency and experience warrant higher-profile feuds​.

Willow Nightingale

Recognized by AEW TBS Champion Mercedes Mone as one of the most promising but underappreciated stars, Nightingale has impressed with her charisma and in-ring skills. Fans and insiders alike believe she could have a significant breakout if given more singles spotlight and prominent matches.

Miro

Known for his powerhouse style, Miro’s appearances have been sporadic, limiting his impact despite his past success in AEW and WWE. Many believe he could shine in the title scene if given a more regular role on AEW’s main shows​

Powerhouse Hobbs

Hobbs, a strong, intimidating force, has struggled with inconsistent booking. Although he has occasionally shown up in significant matches, his potential as a major heel could be tapped further if AEW establishes a more sustained storyline for him​.

Ricky Starks

Despite his exceptional charisma, mic skills, and in-ring versatility, he hasn’t consistently been featured in AEW’s main event storylines. Starks possesses a natural swagger and engaging promo style, drawing comparisons to stars like The Rock, yet he often finds himself in mid-card roles or shorter feuds that don’t capitalize on his potential.

Wardlow

After an intense feud with MJF and a dominant TNT title reign, Wardlow’s push slowed, leaving his fans eager to see him in main event programs where he could showcase his skills against top-tier opponents regularly. His size, intensity, and crowd connection make him a natural choice for AEW’s upper card, but inconsistent booking has limited his growth​.