The old saying is true in AEW: The inmates are running the asylum
Since Full Gear, a lot of people within the industry have come out to criticize AEW for the extreme violence shown on that show, especially the Texas Death Match, which was described by many as complete crap and an example of AEW crossing the line of good taste.
Then, this week, I was surprised to see none other than Kenny Omega come out and criticize his own company over this. This was surprising for several reasons, but mostly because he’s one of the biggest names in the company and somebody you would think Tony Khan would listen to backstage, especially since he made him an EVP of AEW.
So when I read that excerpt from the interview, the first thing that came to my mind was that he’s not wrong. However, I also thought that he probably understands what CM Punk was saying four years ago about AEW and those young guys not wanting to listen to veterans and instead going full speed, risking their health and bodies by taking unnecessary risks just to get noticed.
The old saying is true in AEW: The inmates are running the asylum. That’s mostly because Tony Khan isn’t really a boss in the traditional sense. He’s booking his show to entertain himself, so if somebody like Swerve, Adam Page, or The New Day comes up to him and proposes doing a bunch of super-violent spots for the sake of violence, Tony isn’t going to veto them because he likes that stuff. He’s booking the show for fans like himself, or as he loves to call them, “the sickos.” That does hurt the company a little bit, as newer fans are getting turned off by the product and stopping their viewership of AEW.
The other problem this could cause is that AEW is about to go back to the negotiating table with the new executives at Skydance, a company with $800 billion in debt to pay off that is currently going through a complete restructuring phase. Its main goal right now is to make as much money as possible as quickly as possible.
They just fired James Gunn and Peter Safran from DC Studios because they weren’t making money with their version of the DCEU, so imagine what they might think about AEW right now. Because at the end of the day, everything in entertainment is about the money and playing it as safe as possible.
Let’s look at the history of wrestling on television over the past 20 years to illustrate my point.
In 2000, ECW had a TV deal with TNN, and every week, they had problems with network executives because of how violent the show was. So when TNN was able to get rid of the show and sign a deal with WWE, they dropped ECW, and that was the end of the company.
Then you have the WWE SmackDown on FOX experience. The reason behind the cancellation was mostly money-related because, while SmackDown was the highest-rated non-sports programming on the network, the advertising revenue wasn’t what FOX was expecting. They realized they were better off putting college football in that time slot rather than sticking with professional wrestling, as football was going to bring in a lot more money for the network than anything outside of that industry.
Now, look at the current version of AEW. If you’re one of the new executives at Skydance and you watch some of the stuff that happened on your streaming service at Full Gear and some of the things that happen on Dynamite, are you going to be excited to renegotiate a new deal with AEW knowing that, at any time, something like what happened at Full Gear could happen and make the company look bad with mainstream media, potentially affecting the advertising revenue Skydance would generate from this programming?
I’m not sure about that.
Ratings for AEW Dynamite are pretty strong. Pay-per-view numbers also seem to be strong, even though those figures don’t include how many people bought the shows through HBO Max. But at the end of the day, when you’re dealing with a new company whose goal is to make as few waves as possible and whose main priority is making money, ratings might not matter as much. If they can find another product that can make them more money in that time slot and be less controversial, they could go with that product once the AEW deal is up.
In the end, AEW was built around the motto of being where the best wrestle. It was supposed to have a more sports-based presentation and serve as an alternative to WWE’s more entertainment-based approach.
Let’s fast-forward seven years. While WWE still has an entertainment-style presentation, it has also incorporated a more sports-based approach into its product, giving fans a great mix of the two. Meanwhile, AEW has pretty much turned into a super-indie company that focuses more and more on violence and blood and less and less on actual wrestling, which is far from what the company was originally supposed to be.
Yes, AEW still has some great wrestling, but it’s being overshadowed by the blood-and-guts presentation that the company is embracing right now. When one of your own executives starts criticizing your product publicly, maybe it’s time to sit down with the talent and establish some guidelines about what they can and can’t do in matches.
At the end of the day, while I understand that the sickos love what you’re doing, fans outside that bubble are being turned off by the product. Those are the fans AEW should really be focusing on right now. If the company can grow its audience and get some of those outsiders to watch AEW, that gives it more leverage when negotiating a new TV deal. That’s what’s most important for AEW right now because if Skydance decides to drop the company due to content that doesn’t match its requirements, it could be difficult for AEW to find a new TV deal.
While AEW could always put everything on a streaming service, the money is still in television, even though the cable industry isn’t what it used to be.
So while it’s not too late for AEW to course-correct the direction of the company, I doubt Tony will listen to anybody and make the changes needed to improve his product and get back to what made AEW such a great alternative to WWE: the wrestling.
Also, on a side note, they really need to shorten those pay-per-views, as five hours is way too long for a show and hurts the flow of the event. But that’s for another column.






