My understanding of Ring Psychology vs. Dave Meltzer and some fans of today
Ring psychology and how professional wrestling is today in comparison to 10 years ago, 20 years ago, 30 years ago and 40 years ago is a constant source of material that wrestling fans from all those eras argue about daily within the IWC. Maybe not fans from 40 years ago, but I digress.
I see it on X, which is pretty much a cesspool of some of the most vile tribalist wrestling fans I’ve ever encountered. I also spend a fair bit of time browsing several website comment sections, which will not be named due to the fact that I’m writing for NoDQ. There are plenty of them, though, and I’ve noticed that a lot of these websites and their Disqus comment sections have their regular AEW sickos and WWE diehards constantly at each other’s throats. It’s always going to happen. That’s wrestling fandom for you. Although it felt like IRC chat on mIRC in the early 2000’s, and message forums, didn’t have this level of tribalism! Shit.
Psychology is one of the most misunderstood aspects of professional wrestling, my homies, and I think it’s important to separate ring psychology from technical ability, athleticism and match complexity.
This is just my point of view. You’re more than welcome to disagree, and I promise I won’t lose any sleep over it, and if I do, I’ve always got the cool side of the pillow to soothe me. I hope those that disagree with my thoughts won’t get too upset with me either and we can still be friends. We CAN be gentlemen when it comes to having differing opinions.
I became a pro wrestling fan in 1998. I started Backyard Wrestling in 1999. I became a professional wrestler in 2010. I actually went back to BYW after my run in the Pro’s as a weekend warrior, and eventually hung up the boots in 2017. Anyway, that was nine years ago. It genuinely freaks me out to think that I’ve been obsessed with professional wrestling for… 27 years. Old prick.
Here’s what I think.
Ring psychology isn’t simply about doing impressive moves, having a complicated sequence of counters and reversals or making a match look physically convincing. It’s about understanding how to tell a story inside a wrestling ring, how to make the audience emotionally invested and how to make every action have a freakin’ purpose.
A wrestler can have an incredible moveset and still have terrible ring psychology. Equally, somebody who can barely perform a technically complicated manoeuvre can have outstanding ring psychology. It’s like cooking chicken. You could own every fancy kitchen gadget known to mankind and know 47 different recipes, but if you can’t cook a chicken breast without turning it into a Goodyear tire, you’re not much of a chef. Meanwhile, somebody with just a frying pan, salt and pepper can make an absolute masterpiece. It’s not about how many moves you’ve got in your arsenal. It’s about knowing how to use them.
Len Denton, aka The Grappler, is somebody I’d put in the latter category as it pertains to a Pro Wrestler who wasn’t flashy – but knew ring psychology. I remember once watching what would normally be considered a typical enhancement match on WCW Saturday Night and being absolutely ENTHRALLED by an Eddie Guerrero vs. Len Denton match. There’s nothing particularly spectacular about the match itself, but what you’ve got is a veteran professional wrestler going out there and MAKING Eddie Guerrero. You’ve also got Eddie making Len look like a legitimate threat even though the WCW Audience may not have known him. And that’s an art form in itself.
I’d absolutely put Denton in the conversation when discussing underrated old school workers.
Len Denton Vs Eddie Guerrero
He represents something that I think gets overlooked when people evaluate wrestling purely through match ratings: being a good wrestler isn’t just about what you can do inside the ring. It’s about knowing how to make what you do MATTER!
Ring psychology is the art of making the audience believe that two people are competing against each other, with motivations, strategies, emotions, weaknesses and consequences. It’s about making the audience understand WHY something is happening, rather than simply showing them WHAT is happening.
Take selling for example, god dammit.
If somebody attacks your knee, you should be showing the consequences of that attack throughout the match. You should struggle to put weight on the injured leg, have difficulty getting back to your feet and struggle to execute moves that require the injured leg. Your opponent should deliberately target that weakness, and when you finally make a comeback, the audience should understand what you’re overcoming. What doesn’t make sense is spending five minutes having your knee absolutely destroyed and worked over, beaten on, shat on, only to start running, jumping and performing athletic sequences as if nothing happened. That’s a failure of psychology, regardless of how impressive the moves might look.
Working a body part is an important aspect of professional wrestling. If a heel spends the first half of a match attacking somebody’s arm, there should be a reason for it, right? Perhaps the opponent has a devastating finishing manoeuvre that requires that arm. Perhaps the heel is trying to eliminate their opponent’s ability to hit that manoeuvre. DDP did a masterful job with Goldberg at Halloween Havoc 1998. Goldbergs shoulder was affected to the point that when he went for the Jackhammer, DDP was able to reverse it into the Diamond Cutter. The Diamond Cutter was protected so well you could literally see the fans jumping up and down thinking DDP was actually about to beat Goldberg. Perhaps, the wrestler in control of working the body part has a signature hold that requires them to make the opponent tap out to it, based on the damn body part in question being what the special hold focuses on.
The audience should understand the strategy, and the payoff should matter. If the injured wrestler manages to overcome the damage and execute their finishing move, it should feel like an achievement. That’s what makes the audience care. There’s a reason behind what’s happening, and there’s a reward when the wrestler finally overcomes it.
Character work is equally important. A wrestler’s actions should reflect their personality.
Think about Ric Flair. He’s a cowardly heel who looks for shortcuts, grabs the ropes, complains to the referee and tries to escape when things aren’t going his way. Hulk Hogan was a larger than life babyface who absorbs punishment, feeds off the crowd and eventually summons the strength to fight back. Jake Roberts is a calculating, methodical heel who doesn’t need to perform twenty different moves to make you believe he’s dangerous. Randy Savage was an intensely competitive wrestler whose aggression, desperation and occasional recklessness became part of the match.
Shawn Stasiak was a somewhat clumsy wrestler whose tendency to trip over himself and make questionable decisions became part of his character. Sometimes the biggest threat to Shawn Stasiak’s success was Shawn Stasiak himself. Acknowledge Meat.
These wrestlers aren’t simply performing moves. They’re portraying characters through their wrestling. They’re not memorising 40 spots and visibly trying to remember what comes next as the match is taking place. Not to mention, forgetting about portraying their character amidst all of that. And let’s be honest, there are times these days when you can clearly see professional wrestlers co-operating with one another. It looks like a dance routine rather than a fight. There’s a difference between making something look impressive and making something look believable.
Timing is another massive part of ring psychology. A wrestler needs to understand when to slow things down, when to build anticipation, when to let the audience react and when to deliver the god damn payoff.
A perfectly timed punch can generate a bigger reaction than a complicated sequence of five consecutive reversals. Don’t get me started on the recently controversial Nick Wayne vs. Bandido sequence. I don’t see how they benefited from completely no-selling a bunch of manoeuvres that have been known to end matches in the past. It doesn’t do anything for the match.
Think about Hulk Hogan’s comeback. The finger wag, the crowd getting behind him, the punches, the big boot and the leg drop. It’s simple, but the audience knows exactly what’s happening and becomes emotionally invested.
That’s psychology, ladies and gentlemen. You don’t need 47 different moves to get people out of their seats!
A wrestling match should also have progression. There should be a reason for the heel gaining an advantage, a reason for the babyface making a comeback, a reason for the near falls and a reason for the finish. If you can remove half the sequences from a match without changing anything about the story, you have to question whether those sequences were necessary in the first place! A wrestling match isn’t supposed to be a demonstration of everything two athletes can physically accomplish. It’s supposed to be a contest with a beginning, middle and end.
Now, when it comes to Dave Meltzer, I think there’s a legitimate discussion to be had about the influence his match ratings have had on how modern wrestling fans evaluate matches. I wouldn’t argue that Dave Meltzer knows nothing about ring psychology. He’s watched an extraordinary amount of wrestling and is certainly capable of recognising good storytelling. However, his preferences aren’t necessarily representative of every aspect of what makes professional wrestling great.
One of the biggest criticisms I have of the way his ratings are interpreted is that athleticism and complexity can sometimes receive more attention than the actual storytelling. A wrestler can perform twenty different variations of a suplex, multiple dives to the outside, complicated reversal sequences, incredible aerial manoeuvres and numerous near falls, yet still fail to tell a convincing story.
Just because something is difficult to perform doesn’t automatically make it good professional wrestling. A technically spectacular match can be emotionally empty.
Check out this WWF In Your House match between TAKA Michinoku and Pantera. I think this match was amazing, but it’s rather emotionally empty. The fans cheer for the moves, but nothing is really getting them to stand on their feet and become truly invested.
TAKA Michinoku Vs Pantera
(Please ignore Brian Christopher’s ANNOYING colour commentary, laughter and incessant racist comments. His laughter actually offends me more than anything. And his rotisserie chicken tan.)
Another major issue is selling. One of the biggest problems with modern wrestling is the inconsistent selling of what should be ‘damage’.
You see wrestlers take enormous punishment, suffer seemingly devastating moves and then suddenly return to performing at full capacity. Sometimes wrestlers will take a finishing manoeuvre, get back up, exchange several more moves and take another finishing manoeuvre.
At what point does the audience stop believing that anything actually hurts?
A wrestler making a desperate comeback after absorbing punishment can be fantastic. That’s what professional wrestling is all about. But there needs to be a distinction between a meaningful comeback and simply ignoring everything that happened five minutes earlier.
Darby Allin copping a belly to belly suplex on Steel Stairs should lead to a stretcher job and injury angle, not culminating in being able to defeat PAC a few minutes later. The bump was BRUTAL and CRAZY. Why not get the most out of that and get some sympathy on Darby where we hope he can come back and get his revenge on PAC?
When Kenny Omega kicked out of the One Winged Angel from Will Ospreay at 1 a few years ago (after a STIFF knee to the skull just beforehand, I felt my face get hot in anger. I knew that very moment would end up with copycats. People are going to take that and use it in times where it’s not welcome, because they saw the sicko’s go ballistic over it. I went to a local pro wrestling show here in Perth a few weeks after that and saw some skinny local dude try the same spot in his match and it had no place in the match. It has no place in general.
Kenny Kicks Out At 1
Nonetheless, it’s not ring psychology to kick out of everything and multiple finishers. I don’t understand how people magically should be able to take all this punishment and then no-sell it. Don’t give me that “fighting spirit” BS either. That doesn’t work for me brother. If it works for you then fine, good. I don’t want to yuck your yum.
Near falls are another example. A near fall should make the audience believe that somebody almost won. But when every finishing move is followed by a kick-out, and every subsequent finishing move is supposedly even more devastating, the audience can become desensitised. A near fall is only effective when the audience has a reason to believe that the match could actually end, ya know?
Back in the late ’90s, people would be on their feet for a NON-FINISHING MOVE with a pinfall attempt. Think about that for a second. You didn’t need somebody to get dropped on their head with three finishers before the crowd started losing its mind.
One perfectly executed near fall can be worth more than ten increasingly elaborate ones.
I also think match structure matters considerably more than move quantity. A great wrestling match doesn’t need to be 30 or 40 minutes long.
Some of the greatest matches in wrestling history are relatively short. A 10-15 minute match with excellent pacing, believable selling, character development and a satisfying conclusion can be considerably more effective than a 35-minute athletic exhibition. It makes me think of ‘Lord’ Steven Regal’s WCW Television Title defences, or the feud X-Pac and D’Lo Brown had over the WWF European Championship. The matches didn’t need them to kill one another. They didn’t need to go half an hour to mean something.
Length doesn’t equal quality. Neither does difficulty. Neither does the number of moves performed.
Look at some of the greatest matches in wrestling history.
Randy Savage versus Ricky Steamboat at WrestleMania III in 1987 is a fantastic example of match structure, selling, character work and a storyline injury being incorporated into the actual wrestling. The action has meaning because of what happened before the match. 14 minutes, 35 seconds.
Bret Hart versus Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13 in 1997 is an incredible example of physical storytelling. Austin’s refusal to submit, Bret’s increasing frustration and the eventual double turn create an emotional experience that goes well beyond the moves. 22 minutes and 5 seconds.
Ric Flair versus Ricky Steamboat at Chi-Town Rumble in 1989 is another brilliant example. Two wrestlers who understood positioning, counters, timing, selling and how to make an opponent’s offence look meaningful. Their match tells a story through the wrestling itself. 23 minutes and 18 seconds.
Jerry Lawler versus Terry Funk in their 1981 Empty Arena match is another example of personality, desperation, hatred and making the audience at home believe two people genuinely cannot stand each other. 14 minutes, 56 seconds.
These are the sorts of things that I believe should be at the heart of evaluating professional wrestling. We remember these matches vividly for a reason.
I wouldn’t say Dave Meltzer is incapable of recognising these qualities, but I do think there’s a legitimate argument that his preferred style of wrestling and the match rating culture surrounding him has encouraged some fans to place too much emphasis on athletic spectacle, match length, complexity and dramatic kick outs after near murder.
My overall argument is pretty straight forward.
A great wrestling match isn’t necessarily the match that makes you say, “I can’t believe they managed to do all that.” It’s the match that makes you forget you’re watching two performers executing a predetermined contest. It makes you suspend disbelief, instead of clapping along with your tongue hanging out because the performers did all of their moves to one another. That’s what it feels like these days. Fans were clamoring for AJ Styles to go to AEW to wrestle Ospreay and Omega. Not because of the psychology that would be told, or because of the story being told before the match. In my opinion, it’s just to see them hit their moves on one another.
Please don’t see this as anti-AEW, because I don’t really get into a lot of modern WWE either. I am really not into performers like Seth Rollins either, who has the tools to be an outstanding storyteller, but sometimes he seems more interested in showing you what he can do than making you care about why he’s doing it. Plus he’s as annoying as a fart in a spacesuit.
As I conclude my writing today, you should care about the characters, understand their motivations, believe in their struggles and feel something when the referee counts three.
That’s professional wrestling.
And perhaps the best test of ring psychology is this: could a wrestler make you emotionally invested in a match using nothing more than a punch, selling, a well timed comeback and a convincing finish?
The greats could.
That’s why I wouldn’t automatically put a modern 35-40 minute sequence heavy match above a beautifully constructed 15 minute psychology ridden match from the territory days.
The moves are the tools. The psychology is what makes the match worth watching.
————
Thanks for reading!
Here are my favorite things for the week:
TV Show: Dutton Ranch
Film: Funny Money – The Dane Cook Story
Album: Siamese Dream – The Smashing Pumpkins
Crush: Chelsea Green
Match recommendation of the Week: Steve Austin Vs Bret Hart @ WrestleMania 13
Here’s the songs I listened to as I wrote this article:
Still – Geto Boys / A Bitch Iz A Bitch – N.W.A / White Walls – Still Remains / I Could Care Less – DevilDriver / Dirthouse – Static-X / Whatever – Godsmack / New Disease – Spineshank / Cha Cha Twist – The Detroit Cobras / Bring It – Trapt / Wu-Tang Clan Ain’t Nothin’ to Fuck Wit – Wu-Tang Clan / Bring Me Down – Puddle of Mudd / Arcarsenal – At The Drive-In / Lazaretto – Jack White / The Depths – Of Mice & Men / Super Shooter – RIP SLYME / Come What(ever) May – Stone Sour / Nightmare – Dry Kill Logic / Pretty Fucked Up – Supersuckers / The Show Must Go On – Queen / Everything Sucks – Dope / A.D.I.D.A.S – KoRn / Fast Fuse – Kasabian / Electric Avenue – Skindred / Evil Deeds – Eminem / Get Naked – Methods Of Mayhem / Lexicon Devil – Germs / Cog – The Spine / Breaking Point – Under / Beastie Boys – So What’Cha Want / AC/DC – Shot In The Dark / Semi Charmed Life – Third Eye Blind
If anybody is interested in checking out any of my other stuff…
nWBro’s Podcast on YouTube
https://www.youtube.com/@nWBrosPodcast
nWBro Gaming
https://www.youtube.com/@nWBroGaming
nWBro’s on X
x.com/nWBrosPodcast
nWBro’s on Instagram
instagram.com/nwbrospodcast
nWBro’s on TikTok
tiktok.com/@nwbrospodcast
nWBro’s on Twitch
twitch.tv/nwbro
ECW Ringside Rewind on BitChute
https://www.bitchute.com/ECWRingsideRewind
Also – if any of you remember the old IRC from back in the day, I have a channel with my friend AdamBlast aka BlastMaster on YouTube, called #prowrestling on the Rizon Network. We are pretty much in there all the time with a bunch of other dedicated pro wrestling fans that simply do not want to let go of the nostalgia that is Internet Relay Chat.
https://www.mirc.com/index.html
https://rizon.net
Until next time!
The nWBro






