Toni Storm’s “Timeless” gimmick appears to have been dropped

As seen during the December 10th 2024 “Winter is Coming” edition of AEW Dynamite, Mariah May successfully defended her AEW Women’s Title against Mina Shirakawa.

After the match, Toni Storm made her return to AEW television after being gone since the summer. It appears that Toni has dropped the “Timeless” gimmick as she came out to her old music and was wearing her old ring attire.

Toni recently announced her “retirement” but fans speculated that it was done to set up her surprise return.