Speculation about Mariah May potentially heading to WWE when her AEW contract expires

Mariah May has not appeared in AEW since her loss to Toni Storm at the 2025 Revolution PPV event. After a report came out that Mariah’s contract is expiring later in the year, Mariah posted an Instagram story with the caption “You can’t make the wrong decision because every decision leads you to where you’re supposed to be.”

During Wrestling Observer Radio, Dave Meltzer and Bryan Alvarez of F4WOnline.com discussed the speculation…

Dave Meltzer: “She put a post up, basically saying that I forgot the exact words, but it was saying like there are no mistakes on your journey because you want to get to where you want to be or something. It’s all part of the trip of getting to where you want to be. She had a photo of Orlando, Florida, and I know from people in WWE that they know she wants to go there. I think people saw that cryptic thing. I don’t know when her contract is up. Everyone seems to think it’s the summer that it’s up.”

Bryan Alvarez: “I was given the impression it was a two-year deal that she signed originally. So I guess you can do the math.”

Meltzer: “That would be the summer.”

Alvarez: “But I have heard the same thing that at least in AEW, there’s a belief that she’s heading to WWE.” (quote courtesy of WrestlingNews.co)