Rating for All Out match generates controversy Submitted by Aaron Rift on 09/08/2019 at 06:39 PM
As previously noted, the Young Bucks vs. Lucha Brothers match from All Out received a *****1/2 rating by F4WOnline.com's Dave Meltzer.
The rating has generated controversy due to it ranking higher than Meltzer's ****3/4 for the Edge/Christian vs. Hardyz vs. Dudleyz TLC match from Wrestlemania 17.
Meltzer defended his rating but has continued to get criticism from fans:
Hey remember all your favorite matches from your childhood? They weren’t that good according to Meltzer.
The same goes for the wrestlers. Nick Jackson is so much better than Edge. pic.twitter.com/8G5Phm29JH